Best Lorcana Sets to Grade: Top Grading Value & Gem Premiums

Estimated reading time: 8 min

Key Takeaways

• The First Chapter is often considered a leading Lorcana set for grading ROI with some of the highest PSA 10 premiums and gem rates reported.
• Enchanted Rares across sets like Floodborn and Inklands may offer strong grading value depending on market demand.
• Print quality and centering difficulty can significantly influence gem premium and grading returns.
• PSA is generally preferred for Lorcana due to market liquidity, but CGC also offers competitive grading options for certain chase cards.
• Midpoint’s AI grading tools can assist in pre-assessing centering and surface to help collectors make informed grading decisions.

Choosing which Lorcana sets to grade can impact potential investment returns. With multiple sets released—from The First Chapter to Fabled and beyond—understanding grading values, PSA 10 gem premiums, and which cards to target is important. This guide provides an overview of Lorcana sets by grading ROI, highlights notable chase cards, and discusses how print quality and scarcity may affect grading demand.

Below is a comparison of Lorcana sets to grade based on average PSA 10 premium and grading value, leveraging Midpoint’s trading-card database and AI grading insights.

Raw vs PSA 10 value (biggest grading premium) — live data from Midpoint's card database, as of 2026-09-14. Prices move; Midpoint refreshes these daily.

	Card	Raw	PSA 10	Gem premium
	Ursula's Contract Deep Trouble (2024)	$0.19	$60.00	56.3×
	Mickey Mouse Into the Inklands (2024)	$147.94	$1,080	48.2×
	Cinderella Rise of the Floodborn (2023)	$6.65	$1,181	47.1×
	Mickey Mouse The First Chapter (2023)	$6.67	$4,222	41×
	Scar Promo Expansion 2 (2024)	$46.36	$1,570	35.5×
	Ariel Ursula's Return (2024)	$182.76	$1,094	34.1×
	Mufasa Shimmering Skies (2024)	$375.35	$968.56	31.9×
	We Could Be Immortals Azurite Sea (2024)	$0.64	$797.37	30.9×
	Stitch Promo Expansion 1 (2022)	$298.10	$1,645	23.3×
	Cinderella Promo Expansion 3 (2025)	—	$2,672	20.1×
	Moana Winterspell (2026)	$13.01	$4,110	15.7×
	Stitch Reign of Jafar (2025)	$380.06	$2,493	14.9×

Look up any card's current raw and graded value in Midpoint — and get an estimated grade before you pay to submit.

1. The First Chapter: Premier Grading Value & Highest PSA 10 Premium

The First Chapter is widely regarded as a strong Lorcana set to grade for potential profit. It often commands some of the highest average PSA 10 gem premiums, sometimes reported in the range of 5-10x raw value, attributed to factors like scarcity, early print quality challenges, and popular chase cards such as Elsa and Mickey.

Elsa’s raw value is around $60, with PSA 10 copies reported to sell for significantly higher prices, illustrating the premium grading can add. This set’s print runs have centering challenges that can make gem grades less common and potentially more valuable.

• Key chase cards: Elsa, Mickey, Maleficent, Stitch.
• Gem premium: Often high for top Enchanted Rares.
• Best grading company: PSA is commonly preferred for population and resale liquidity.

2. Floodborn: Strong Enchanted Rares & Solid Grading ROI

Floodborn is considered a notable set for grading investment, especially for its Enchanted Rares. Cards like Ariel and Moana have shown PSA 10 premiums typically in the range of 4-6x raw value, influenced by print quality and collector interest.

While not as scarce as The First Chapter, Floodborn’s card centering can present some challenges, making gem grades valuable but potentially more attainable with careful pre-grading evaluation.

• Key chase cards: Ariel, Moana.
• Gem premium: Generally moderate on select cards.
• Print quality: Improved but with some centering variance.

3. Inklands: Notable Enchanted Rares for PSA/CGC Grading

Inklands offers some of the notable Enchanted Rares to grade, particularly for collectors who consider CGC grading alongside PSA. Cards like Maleficent have been reported to achieve gem premiums around 5x raw price in some cases, partly due to lower CGC population.

Print quality is generally higher, though centering can still be a challenge. Midpoint’s centering measurement tool can assist in pre-submission assessment.

• Key chase cards: Maleficent, Ursula.
• Gem premium: Can be significant on top rares.
• Preferred grading: PSA for liquidity; CGC for low population cards.

4. Ursula’s Return: Moderate Grading Value with Niche Appeal

Ursula’s Return may offer moderate grading potential, with some chase cards showing gem premiums in the 3-4x range. Print quality and centering are generally better, but larger print runs may reduce scarcity.

Collectors focusing on characters like Ursula might find grading worthwhile, though overall grading ROI may be lower compared to earlier sets.

• Key chase cards: Ursula, unique variants.
• Gem premium: Moderate relative to earlier sets.
• Centering: Easier than The First Chapter but still relevant.

5. Shimmering Skies: Emerging Grading Interest

Shimmering Skies has shown growing interest among graders due to certain high-demand character cards. PSA 10 premiums are generally lower than older sets but may increase as the set matures and scarcity develops.

Print quality is relatively consistent, making gem grades more attainable, which could lower premiums but increase grading success rates.

• Key chase cards: Stitch, newer Enchanted Rares.
• Gem premium: Typically modest.
• Print quality: Stable; centering generally easier.

6. Azurite Sea & Fabled: Later Sets with Lower Grading ROI

Azurite Sea and Fabled are later Lorcana sets where grading ROI appears lower. Larger print runs and improved centering tend to reduce scarcity and gem premiums, often reported under 2x raw value.

These sets may be worth grading primarily if cards have unique misprints, miscuts, or other rare variants.

• Key chase cards: Limited high-demand rares.
• Gem premium: Generally lower.
• Best grading approach: Selective, based on raw card condition.

7. How Print Quality & Centering Affect Grading ROI Across Lorcana Sets

Print quality and centering difficulty are important factors influencing gem premium and grading ROI in Lorcana. Earlier sets like The First Chapter have more centering challenges and print imperfections, which can make PSA 10 grades less common and potentially more valuable.

Midpoint’s AI digital grading and centering measurement tools help collectors evaluate a card’s centering precisely, which may improve grading success rates and ROI.

• Better centering can increase PSA 10 gem rate and resale premium.
• Print inconsistencies in early sets contribute to grading scarcity.
• Later sets generally have improved print quality, which may lower grading premiums.

8. Which Characters & Cards Are the Main Grading Chases by Set?

Top grading chases vary by set but often include marquee characters with collector interest:

• The First Chapter: Elsa, Mickey, Maleficent, Stitch
• Floodborn: Ariel, Moana
• Inklands: Maleficent, Ursula
• Ursula’s Return: Ursula variants
• Shimmering Skies: Stitch, newer Enchanted Rares

Focusing grading submissions on these chase cards may help maximize potential gem premiums and resale value.

9. Determining Which Lorcana Cards Are Worth Grading

Not all Lorcana cards are necessarily worth grading due to grading fees and resale premiums. Cards generally worth grading tend to have:

• Higher raw value (often $20 or more).
• Strong PSA 10 gem premiums (commonly 3x or more raw value).
• Chase or signature Enchanted Rares with collector demand.
• Potential scarcity or print imperfections that limit gem grade supply.

Using tools like Midpoint's grading estimate can help pre-grade cards and avoid unnecessary grading fees.

10. Choosing Between PSA, CGC, and BGS for Lorcana Grading

PSA remains the preferred grading company for Lorcana due to its market presence, population, and resale liquidity. CGC is gaining attention for rare chase cards with low CGC populations and may command competitive premiums.

BGS is less commonly used for Lorcana but can be valuable for specific cards with strong surface or centering grades.

• PSA: Best for mainstream market appeal and liquidity.
• CGC: Useful for low-population, high-premium chase cards.
• BGS: Selective use, especially for surface-focused grading.

11. How Set Scarcity & Reprint Risk Impact Grading Demand and Long-Term Value

Scarcity is a key driver of grading demand; The First Chapter’s limited print run supports higher PSA 10 premiums. Later sets with larger print runs and potential reprints may see reduced grading ROI.

Collectors should stay informed about reprint announcements and population reports to avoid overgrading cards that could saturate the market and depress premiums.

• Lower scarcity sets often have lower gem premiums.
• Higher scarcity can sustain or increase grading demand.
• Reprint risk may reduce long-term grading value.

Conclusion

For collectors and investors considering Lorcana grading, The First Chapter is often viewed as the leading set with some of the highest PSA 10 premiums and grading ROI. Floodborn and Inklands also offer notable grading value, particularly for Enchanted Rares. Later sets like Ursula’s Return and Shimmering Skies may be suitable for selective grading, while Azurite Sea and Fabled generally show lower returns.

Understanding print quality, centering difficulty, and grading company preferences can help improve grading outcomes. Tools like Midpoint provide AI-powered digital grading estimates and precise centering measurements to assist collectors in maximizing grading investments and portfolio tracking.

FAQ

Q: Which Lorcana set is the best to grade for profit?

A: The First Chapter is widely regarded as a top set for grading profit due to its high PSA 10 gem premiums, scarcity, and popular chase cards like Elsa and Mickey.

Q: Are Enchanted Rares the only Lorcana cards worth grading?

A: While Enchanted Rares often offer the highest grading premiums, some other rare or misprinted cards may also be worth grading depending on raw value and demand.

Q: What Lorcana cards should I send to PSA or CGC?

A: PSA is generally preferred for most Lorcana cards due to market liquidity, but CGC can be a good option for low-population chase cards that may fetch higher premiums.

Q: Is The First Chapter the best Lorcana set to grade?

A: The First Chapter is commonly viewed as leading Lorcana sets in grading ROI and PSA 10 premium, making it a strong candidate for grading and investment.

Q: How do I know if a Lorcana card is worth grading?

A: Using grading tools like Midpoint to estimate PSA 10 gem premiums and evaluate centering and surface condition can help decide if grading fees are justified.

Q: Which Lorcana set has the highest PSA 10 value?

A: The First Chapter is generally recognized as having some of the highest PSA 10 values and premiums across multiple chase cards compared to other Lorcana sets.