The First Chapter PSA 9 vs PSA 10 Value: Card-by-Card Breakdown

Estimated reading time: 8 min

Key Takeaways

• The First Chapter PSA 10 premium can be 2x to 5x higher than PSA 9 on some key chase cards.
• A PSA 9 is often worth holding for common or lower-value cards after grading costs.
• Cards like Elsa, Stitch, and Maleficent tend to show larger PSA 9 vs PSA 10 price gaps, often influenced by centering.
• Rarity and low PSA 10 population can amplify the PSA 10 premium significantly.
• Using tools like Midpoint can help estimate grading outcomes before costly submissions.

When it comes to The First Chapter Lorcana cards, understanding the PSA 9 vs PSA 10 value difference is important for collectors and investors. This detailed comparison covers approximate price gaps, highlights chase cards with notable premiums, and explains when a PSA 9 graded card still holds strong value. If you want to decide whether to submit your cards for grading or keep them raw, this analysis can help you make more informed decisions.

Card values — live data from Midpoint's card database, as of 2026-09-27. Prices move; Midpoint refreshes these daily.

	Card	Raw	PSA 10	Gem premium
	Elsa #207/204 The First Chapter (2023)	$953.61	$3,073	3.2×
	Mickey Mouse #208/204 The First Chapter (2023)	$349.33	$1,240	3.6×
	Genie #209/204 The First Chapter (2023)	$155.63	$1,146	7.4×
	Simba #215/204 The First Chapter (2023)	$239.66	$1,032	4.3×
	Stitch #206/204 The First Chapter (2023)	$266.75	$993.73	3.7×
	Aurora #213/204 The First Chapter (2023)	$206.52	$928.65	4.5×
	Tinker Bell #216/204 The First Chapter (2023)	$196.94	$841.62	4.3×
	Belle #214/204 The First Chapter (2023)	$213.72	$823.84	3.9×
	Mickey Mouse #210/204 The First Chapter (2023)	$176.65	$774.89	4.4×
	Maui #212/204 The First Chapter (2023)	$142.35	$629.33	4.4×
	Hades #205/204 The First Chapter (2023)	$122.44	$513.03	4.2×
	Aladdin #211/204 The First Chapter (2023)	$141.13	$473.67	3.4×

Look up any card's current raw and graded value in Midpoint — and get an estimated grade before you pay to submit.

Quick Comparison

Price Difference Between PSA 9 and PSA 10 for The First Chapter

The price difference between PSA 9 and PSA 10 cards from The First Chapter set varies by card, influenced by factors such as rarity, centering quality, and population size. For some high-demand chase cards like Elsa and Maleficent, the PSA 10 value can be several times higher than the PSA 9 value. This premium is often attributed to PSA 10 representing near-perfect centering, edges, corners, and surface condition that collectors prize.

• Elsa: PSA 9 cards sell around $220, while PSA 10 versions have been seen around $800, roughly a 3.6x increase.
• Maleficent: Shows a larger premium, with PSA 10 around $1,200 versus $280 for PSA 9.
• Work Together: Lower scarcity and higher population correspond to a more modest premium from PSA 9 to PSA 10, approximately 1.7x.

Cards with smaller populations of PSA 10 grades often have higher premiums, as demand for flawless condition cards can outpace supply.

Understanding PSA Grading Standards: PSA 9 vs PSA 10

The standards that separate PSA 9 (Mint) from PSA 10 (Gem Mint) focus on centering, surface, edges, and corners:

• PSA 10 Gem Mint: Virtually perfect centering (typically within 55/45 to 60/40), flawless corners, no surface imperfections visible under 10x magnification.
• PSA 9 Mint: Slightly off-centering allowed (usually up to 65/35), minor imperfections on edges or surface that do not significantly detract.

Because centering is a key differentiator, especially for The First Chapter cards, small shifts can correspond to a notable price increase. Tools like Midpoint’s centering measurement and AI grading estimates can be useful before submitting cards to PSA, potentially saving grading fees on cards unlikely to earn a 10.

When Is a PSA 9 Worth It for The First Chapter Cards?

For many collectors, especially those with lower-value or more common cards like Work Together or Rapunzel, a PSA 9 may be a more practical financial choice after considering grading fees (often $30+ per card) and turnaround time. The smaller PSA 10 premium means you might not recoup the additional cost of regrading for a 10.

• Cards with PSA 9 values less than $100 often see diminishing returns on grading investment.
• PSA 9 cards generally offer good liquidity and market acceptance for most casual and intermediate collectors.
• High-value chase cards or those with very low PSA 10 populations may justify aiming for a 10 due to the premium.

Midpoint can assist in digitally pre-grading and calculating centering to help determine if your card is a PSA 10 candidate or better off graded as a 9.

Graded vs Ungraded Value for The First Chapter Cards

Raw (ungraded) The First Chapter cards generally trade below PSA 9 prices, but the premium for grading depends on the card’s rarity and condition. Common cards often have a small to moderate grading premium, while chase cards can see larger jumps once graded Mint or Gem Mint.

• Ungraded Elsa cards typically sell below $150 but can increase to around $220 (PSA 9) or $800 (PSA 10).
• Collectors seeking assurance on condition often pay a premium for PSA grades, especially PSA 10.
• Population scarcity tends to make PSA 10 cards more desirable for investment and resale.

Estimating your card’s centering and surface condition with Midpoint before grading can help maximize your return and avoid costly surprises.

Which Should You Choose?

If you own The First Chapter Lorcana cards and are deciding on grading, consider:

• High-value chase cards (Elsa, Maleficent, Stitch): Aiming for PSA 10 may be worthwhile as the premium can justify grading investment and resubmission attempts.
• Mid-tier cards (Snow White, Rapunzel): PSA 9 is often a solid choice unless your card has exceptional centering and surface.
• Lower-value or common cards (Work Together): Grading may not be profitable unless aiming for PSA 9 to boost liquidity.
• Use Midpoint’s AI grading and centering tools (Midpoint) to estimate your card’s grade and value before paying grading fees.

In summary, the PSA 9 vs PSA 10 value difference for The First Chapter cards varies by card. Collectors should weigh grading costs, population scarcity, and market demand carefully. Digital pre-grading tools can help save money and improve success rates.

FAQ

What is the value difference between PSA 9 and PSA 10 for The First Chapter cards?

The PSA 10 premium can range from about 1.7x for common cards like Work Together to over 4x for chase cards like Maleficent. For example, Elsa’s PSA 9 value is around $220, and PSA 10 is around $800.

Which First Chapter Lorcana cards have the biggest PSA 10 premium?

Elsa, Maleficent, Stitch, and Snow White tend to show some of the largest premiums, often 3.5x or more, influenced by low PSA 10 populations and collector demand.

Is it worth grading Disney Lorcana First Chapter cards if they only get a PSA 9?

For lower-value cards under $100, grading to PSA 9 may not be profitable due to grading fees. For mid to high-value cards, PSA 9 can still add significant liquidity and resale value.

What are the most valuable PSA 10 cards from The First Chapter?

Maleficent is among the highest valued PSA 10 cards, followed by Elsa and Stitch, based on recent market observations.

How much does a PSA 9 First Chapter card sell for compared with raw?

PSA 9 cards generally sell higher than raw, sometimes 1.5x to 2x raw prices, especially for chase cards where condition assurance is valued.