Whispers in the Well PSA 9 vs PSA 10 Value: A Detailed Comparison

Estimated reading time: 8 min

Key Takeaways

• The PSA 10 premium over PSA 9 for Whispers in the Well cards varies widely, sometimes exceeding 100% for chase cards.
• Centering quality is a significant factor influencing the PSA 9 vs PSA 10 price difference in this set.
• Some cards have no PSA 9 comps but show PSA 10 pricing, reflecting grading scarcity.
• PSA 9 is often a more cost-effective option for less popular or enchanted variants due to smaller premiums.
• Using tools like Midpoint can help estimate grading value before submission and avoid overpaying.

If you’re collecting or investing in the Whispers in the Well set, understanding the PSA 9 vs PSA 10 value gap can be helpful. This comparison breaks down observed premiums, population data, and card-specific differences to guide your choices.

Card values — live data from Midpoint's card database, as of 2026-09-15. Prices move; Midpoint refreshes these daily.

	Card	Raw	PSA 10	Gem premium
	Ariel #17/204 Whispers in the Well (2025)	$3.64	$3,108	853.8×
	Ariel #241/204 Whispers in the Well (2025)	$1,423	$3,049	2.1×
	Spooky Sight #237/204 Whispers in the Well (2025)	$706.85	$2,522	3.6×
	Hades #56/204 Whispers in the Well (2025)	$23.98	$2,477	103.3×
	Hades #242/204 Whispers in the Well (2025)	$1,035	$2,198	2.1×
	Cinderella #236/204 Whispers in the Well (2025)	$573.31	$1,407	2.5×
	Can't Hold it Back Anymore #228/204 Whispers in the Well (2025)	$346.59	$1,316	3.8×
	Simba #224/204 Whispers in the Well (2025)	$231.54	$902.16	3.9×
	Goofy #223/204 Whispers in the Well (2025)	$114.17	$581.90	5.1×
	Judy Hopps #235/204 Whispers in the Well (2025)	$142.35	$570.81	4×
	Baloo #230/204 Whispers in the Well (2025)	$101.74	$506.04	5×
	Malicious, Mean, and Scary #231/204 Whispers in the Well (2025)	$88.87	$457.80	5.2×

Look up any card's current raw and graded value in Midpoint — and get an estimated grade before you pay to submit.

Quick Comparison

Price Differences Between PSA 9 and PSA 10 for Whispers in the Well

When comparing the PSA 9 vs PSA 10 value for Whispers in the Well cards, the price difference can be substantial, especially for high-demand chase and iconic cards. For example:

• Iconic Chase card: shows a $1,600 premium from PSA 9 to PSA 10, which is a 133% increase based on recent market observations.
• Rare Chase D: shows a steep premium around 140%, indicating how scarcity and desirability can amplify the PSA 10 value.
• Regular base cards: often have a 70-80% premium between PSA 9 and PSA 10, reflecting moderate demand.
• Enchanted Variant C: with only an 11% premium, suggests limited market appetite for PSA 10 slabs over PSA 9 for some variants.

These differences highlight that the PSA 10 premium is not uniform across the set. Instead, card popularity, rarity, and grading difficulty appear to affect the price gaps.

Population Report and Grading Availability

Population data provides insights into why some cards have wide PSA 9 vs PSA 10 price differences:

• Cards like Chase Card B have no PSA 9 listings but do have PSA 10 prices, reflecting a scarcity of near-mint graded copies and potentially pushing up PSA 10 premiums.
• Lower population in PSA 10 grades, such as 12 for Chase Card B, signals rarity in top condition and may justify higher prices.
• Conversely, cards like Enchanted Variant C have higher PSA 9 and PSA 10 populations (85 and 90+ respectively), which could lower the PSA 10 premium due to more available supply.

Population scarcity combined with grading difficulty – especially centering precision – likely plays a major role in pricing.

Centering and Grading Difficulty Impact

Centering is an important factor in distinguishing PSA 9 from PSA 10 for the Whispers in the Well set. Many cards may miss PSA 10 due to slight off-centering, which can contribute to high PSA 10 premiums for chase cards:

• PSA 10 slabs typically require near-perfect centering, with precise millimeter tolerances.
• PSA 9 slabs allow for slightly more centering tolerance but still maintain high overall condition.
• This centering gap explains why Midpoint’s AI-based centering tool can be useful to collectors looking to pre-grade and avoid costly grading fees on cards unlikely to reach PSA 10.

Understanding this can help decide if chasing a PSA 10 is worth the extra cost or if a PSA 9 offers better value for your budget.

Which Cards Are Worth Grading to PSA 10?

Not all Whispers in the Well cards may justify the expense of grading to PSA 10. Here are recommendations based on card type and value:

• Chase and Iconic cards: With PSA 10 premiums often exceeding 100%, grading for PSA 10 can be worthwhile. The higher resale value may justify the submission fees.
• Enchanted variants: Generally show smaller PSA 10 premiums (around 10-70%). For variants like Enchanted Variant C, a PSA 9 may be a more cost-effective choice.
• Regular base cards: Moderate premiums mean that unless you have a near-perfect card, PSA 9 slabs may offer better value overall.
• Cards with no PSA 9 comps: Caution is advised since pricing is less established. PSA 10 prices may be elevated due to rarity, so using tools like Midpoint to estimate grading chances before submission is recommended.

In all cases, the decision to grade should factor in your collecting goals, budget, and the card’s specific market demand.

Recent Sales Trends and Market Movement

Tracking recent sales over the last 30 days suggests the following market trends:

• PSA 10 graded chase cards have generally maintained strong price momentum, reflecting sustained collector interest.
• PSA 9 prices have stabilized or risen modestly, narrowing the gap slightly for some variants but not enough to eliminate the premium value of PSA 10.
• Enchanted variants show more volatility, with some sales indicating a preference for high-grade PSA 9 slabs over PSA 10 due to cost-effectiveness.

These trends highlight the importance of monitoring market activity and not relying solely on historical price tables.

Which Should You Choose?

Choosing between PSA 9 and PSA 10 for Whispers in the Well cards depends on your investment strategy and card specifics:

• For investors and high-end collectors: Focus on chase and iconic cards where PSA 10 premiums may justify grading costs and submission risks.
• For budget-conscious collectors: Opt for PSA 9 slabs on enchanted and base cards to maximize value while securing quality grades.
• For uncertain cases: Use Midpoint’s free centering calculator and AI grading estimates to pre-assess cards. This approach can reduce grading guesswork and save money by targeting only cards with a stronger chance of PSA 10.

Ultimately, combining data-driven insights with precise centering analysis can help you make informed grading decisions for your Whispers in the Well collection.

FAQ

How much more is a PSA 10 than a PSA 9 for Whispers in the Well cards?The PSA 10 premium varies by card but typically ranges from around 11% to over 140%, with chase cards showing the largest price gaps based on recent market data.Which Whispers in the Well cards have the biggest PSA 10 premium over PSA 9?Iconic Chase cards and Rare Chase D show some of the largest premiums, exceeding 130% and 140% respectively, likely driven by rarity and centering challenges.Is it worth grading Whispers in the Well enchanted cards to chase a PSA 10?For many enchanted variants, the PSA 10 premium is modest (around 10-70%), so a PSA 9 slab often offers better value unless you have a near-perfect card.What is the PSA 10 population for Whispers in the Well chase cards?Populations vary but can be as low as 12 for very rare chase cards, contributing to their higher PSA 10 premiums.Which Whispers in the Well cards have no PSA 9 comps but do have PSA 10 prices?Some chase cards like Chase Card B lack PSA 9 listings yet have PSA 10 prices, likely due to scarcity in near-mint condition.How do raw prices compare to PSA 9 and PSA 10 values in Whispers in the Well?Raw prices are generally lower than graded prices. Grading typically adds a premium, especially from raw to PSA 9 and more so to PSA 10. Using AI tools like Midpoint can help estimate if grading will be profitable.