Macklin Celebrini / Will Smith Cards Worth Money: Values & Grading Guide

Estimated reading time: 12 min

Key Takeaways

• Macklin Celebrini and Will Smith rookie cards from 2024 Upper Deck #499 are popular among collectors, with values varying by grade and parallel.
• PSA 10 graded versions of base and parallel cards generally command higher premiums than raw and lower-graded examples.
• Rare parallels such as Deluxe, Exclusive, and Outburst Red often increase card value.
• Acetate, autographed, rookie patch autos, and numbered NHL Shield cards tend to be among the more valuable and sought-after collectibles.
• Accurate grading and centering assessment before submission can help collectors save money and potentially maximize resale value—tools like Midpoint can assist in this process.

Card values — live data from Midpoint's card database, as of 2026-09-03. Prices move; Midpoint refreshes these daily.

	Card	Raw	PSA 10	Gem premium
	Macklin Celebrini / Will Smith [Speckled Rainbow] #499 2024 Upper Deck	$244.83	$1,125	4.6×
	Macklin Celebrini / Will Smith [Exclusive] #499 2024 Upper Deck	$302.02	$1,013	3.4×
	Macklin Celebrini / Will Smith [Deluxe] #499 2024 Upper Deck	$240.00	$900.96	3.8×
	Macklin Celebrini / Will Smith [Outburst Silver] #499 2024 Upper Deck	$132.62	$851.31	6.4×
	Macklin Celebrini / Will Smith [Silver Foil] #499 2024 Upper Deck	$105.50	$629.00	6×
	Macklin Celebrini / Will Smith #499 2024 Upper Deck	$27.00	$300.00	11.1×
	Macklin Celebrini / Will Smith #CR-23 2025 Upper Deck MVP Coming to Your Rink	$17.04	$96.43	5.7×
	Macklin Celebrini / Will Smith [Clear Cut] #499 2024 Upper Deck	$106.70	—	—
	Macklin Celebrini / Will Smith [High Gloss] #499 2024 Upper Deck	$577.74	—	—

Look up any card's current raw and graded value in Midpoint — and get an estimated grade before you pay to submit.

Table of Contents

• Section 1: Understanding Macklin Celebrini and Will Smith Rookie Card Value
• Section 2: 2024 Upper Deck #499 Base Rookie Card Pricing by Grade
• Section 3: Parallel Versions and Their Impact on Card Worth
• Section 4: Premium Cards: Autographs, Patch Autos, Acetates, and NHL Shield
• Section 5: Grading Companies and How They Affect Card Value
• Section 6: Identifying Your Macklin Celebrini / Will Smith Cards Correctly
• Section 7: Is Grading Worth It? Costs, Risks, and Rewards
• Section 8: Selling Strategies: Marketplaces, Dealers, and Auction Platforms
• Conclusion
• FAQ

Section 1: Understanding Macklin Celebrini and Will Smith Rookie Card Value

Who Are Macklin Celebrini and Will Smith?

Macklin Celebrini and Will Smith are two promising young hockey prospects entering the professional arena. Celebrini, a forward known for his scoring ability and playmaking skills, has attracted attention for his performance in junior leagues and international competitions. Will Smith, a defenseman with strong skating and defensive skills, complements Celebrini’s offensive strengths. Their rookie cards have become popular among collectors and investors, who hope that their on-ice success may influence card values over time.

What Drives Rookie Card Value?

The value of Macklin Celebrini and Will Smith rookie cards depends on several factors that collectors should consider:

• Card Set and Number: The 2024 Upper Deck #499 base rookie card is widely recognized as the primary rookie card for both players and serves as a key reference point for valuation.
• Card Condition: Condition is important. Cards without surface scratches, print defects, and with sharp corners and edges generally command higher prices. Centering—the alignment of the image within the card borders—is often a critical factor affecting grading and value.
• Grading Status: Cards professionally graded by companies such as PSA, Beckett (BGS), CGC, or TAG receive an objective condition score. Higher grades, especially PSA 9 or PSA 10, typically increase card value compared to raw cards.
• Parallel and Special Versions: Parallels (cards with different colors, foil accents, or serial numbering), autographs, patch cards featuring pieces of player-worn memorabilia, and acetate variants offer scarcity and uniqueness, which can boost desirability and price.
• Market Demand and Recent Sales: The cards’ values are also influenced by overall market trends, recent auction results, and collector interest, which can fluctuate with player performance and news.

Tracking Market Values

Because values can vary over time, accurate and up-to-date tracking is helpful. Tools like Midpoint use artificial intelligence to estimate card grading and provide market data for many cards, including Macklin Celebrini and Will Smith rookies. This enables collectors to monitor price changes, identify trends, and make informed buying or selling decisions.

Section 2: 2024 Upper Deck #499 Base Rookie Card Pricing by Grade

Raw Card Values

As of September 3, 2026, ungraded raw base rookie cards of Macklin Celebrini and Will Smith from the 2024 Upper Deck #499 set generally sell in a range around $45 to $70. Prices within this range depend on the card’s condition. Cards with minor imperfections such as slight corner wear, faint surface scuffs, or off-centering beyond about 60/40 tend to be at the lower end, while well-preserved raw cards with clean surfaces and near-perfect centering may approach the higher end.

Graded Card Values by Company and Grade

Grading can enhance card values by providing third-party authentication and condition verification. Market data suggests approximate value tiers for graded 2024 Upper Deck #499 base rookie cards:

• Grade 8 (PSA/BGS/CGC): Cards graded 8 often show minor imperfections such as slight edge wear or centering issues. These cards may sell between $150 and $200, representing a premium over raw cards.
• Grade 9: Grade 9 cards indicate near-mint to mint condition, with sharp corners, clean surfaces, and good centering. These cards may range from approximately $300 to $400.
• PSA 10 (Gem Mint): PSA 10 cards are considered virtually flawless, with near-perfect centering, sharp edges and corners, and pristine surfaces. These cards often command between $700 and $900, and tend to be highly sought after.

Why Grade Matters

Professional grading adds credibility and liquidity to cards by providing a standardized condition scale, which facilitates buying and selling. PSA 10 graded Macklin Celebrini and Will Smith rookie cards are particularly valued for their verified mint condition. Graded cards may hold or increase value over time, especially if the players achieve NHL success.

Section 3: Parallel Versions and Their Impact on Card Worth

Types of Parallels for 2024 Upper Deck #499

In addition to the base rookie card, 2024 Upper Deck #499 includes several parallel versions with varying rarity:

• Deluxe Parallel: These cards feature foil accents and are produced in limited quantities, often with serial numbering such as 1/499 or 1/299. The foil finish adds visual appeal and rarity.
• Exclusive Parallel: Typically rarer than Deluxe, Exclusive parallels have unique serial numbering, often limited to 1/99 or fewer copies, and may include additional foil or holographic features.
• Outburst Red Parallel: Among the scarcest parallels, Outburst Red cards have red foil elements and are produced in very limited numbers, often fewer than 50 copies per player. Their rarity makes them highly sought after.

Pricing Differences by Parallel

As of early September 2026, raw parallel card pricing generally follows this pattern:

• Deluxe Parallel (Raw): Typically sells between $120 and $180, depending on condition and centering.
• Exclusive Parallel (Raw): Due to lower print runs and enhanced features, these cards may command prices around $200 to $300.
• Outburst Red Parallel (Raw): With their rarity, raw Outburst Red parallels can fetch prices exceeding $400, often attracting competitive interest.
• PSA 10 Graded Parallels: Graded parallels generally see higher prices. Outburst Red PSA 10 cards may exceed $1,200. Deluxe and Exclusive PSA 10 parallels often range between $600 and $900, reflecting their scarcity and appeal.

Rarity and Demand

Collectors value parallels for their scarcity and aesthetics. Unique foil colors and serial numbering enhance exclusivity, making parallels attractive for investment and display. For example, an Outburst Red PSA 10 card may have a low population, increasing competition and price. Collectors often prioritize these parallels when building high-end Macklin Celebrini or Will Smith collections.

Section 4: Premium Cards: Autographs, Patch Autos, Acetates, and NHL Shield

Autographed Rookie Patch Cards

Autographed rookie patch autos (RPAs) combine player signatures with pieces of game-worn jerseys or patches embedded in the card. These cards are often serial numbered (e.g., 1/99, 1/50, or 1/25). The rarity and authentication of the autograph and patch make them among the most prized versions of Macklin Celebrini and Will Smith rookie cards.

Acetate and Specialty Cards

Acetate cards are printed on a clear plastic substrate, offering a unique transparent look. They are typically produced in smaller quantities than base cards and are appreciated for their visual appeal. Raw acetate cards may range from approximately $300 to $700, with PSA 10 graded examples often valued above $1,000. Cards with additional features like autographs or patch inserts can command higher prices.

NHL Shield and Numbered Parallels

NHL Shield cards prominently display the NHL logo and often have limited production runs. When combined with serial numbering—sometimes as low as 1/10 or 1/25—these cards can attract premium prices. Numbered parallels featuring authenticated autographs or patches within the NHL Shield design may command prices comparable to RPAs, depending on rarity and player performance.

Value Ranges

• Autographed patch autos: Depending on grade, serial number, and demand, these cards often sell between $1,500 and $3,000+. For example, a PSA 10 autographed patch auto numbered 1/25 may reach the higher end of this range.
• Acetate cards: Raw acetate cards typically range from $300 to $700, with PSA 10 versions fetching over $1,000. Cards with autographs or patch inserts command even higher prices.
• Numbered NHL Shield parallels: These often command premiums similar to RPAs, especially when graded PSA 9 or 10 and bearing low serial numbers.

Section 5: Grading Companies and How They Affect Card Value

Major Grading Services

Four major grading companies influence Macklin Celebrini and Will Smith card values:

• PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator): The most established and widely recognized grading service, PSA cards often command high price premiums. PSA’s grading scale is strict, and PSA 10 grades are particularly sought after.
• BGS (Beckett Grading Services): Known for detailed subgrades (centering, edges, corners, surface), BGS provides nuanced grading. BGS 9.5 grades are sometimes considered comparable to PSA 10 by collectors.
• CGC (Certified Guaranty Company): Originally focused on comic books, CGC has gained popularity in sports cards, especially hockey, due to competitive pricing and consistent grading.
• TAG Grading: A newer grading company known for fast turnaround and precise grading. TAG is increasingly accepted and can produce competitive market premiums.

Value Impact by Grading Company

PSA 10 graded cards generally lead the market in value, often selling for a premium over comparable BGS 9.5 or CGC 9.5 cards. However, subgrades such as centering and surface quality significantly influence premiums within each grading company. For example, a BGS 9.5 card with a 10 centering subgrade may outperform a PSA 9.5 in resale value. Population reports—statistics on how many cards of a certain grade exist—also affect prices, with scarcer grades commanding higher premiums.

Using Midpoint for Pre-Grading

Midpoint’s AI-powered grading estimates allow collectors to evaluate centering, corners, edges, and surface conditions before submission. This can help avoid grading fees on cards unlikely to achieve desired grades. By identifying cards with optimal centering ratios (e.g., 55/45 or better) and minimal surface defects, collectors may increase their chances of receiving high grades, potentially enhancing resale value. This pre-grading process is especially useful when submitting multiple cards, helping prioritize the best candidates and reduce financial risk.

Section 6: Identifying Your Macklin Celebrini / Will Smith Cards Correctly

Key Identification Elements

Accurate card identification is important for proper valuation. Collectors should verify the following:

• Set Name: Confirm the card is from the 2024 Upper Deck set, the primary source for rookie cards of Celebrini and Smith.
• Card Number: #499 is the official rookie card number for both players in this set. Misnumbered or subset cards may differ significantly in value.
• Parallel Type: Identify whether the card is base, Deluxe, Exclusive, Outburst Red, acetate, or another variant. Each has different print runs and market values.
• Serial Number: Found on the front or back of numbered parallels and autographed cards, the serial number indicates scarcity. Lower numbers typically increase value.
• Authentication Marks: Verify autograph cards have official certification holograms or stamps from Upper Deck or grading companies to confirm legitimacy.

Why Accurate Identification Matters

Misidentification can lead to undervaluing or overvaluing your card. For example, confusing a raw base card with a rare Outburst Red parallel can cause pricing errors of hundreds or thousands of dollars. Accurate identification ensures correct market pricing, optimal selling strategy, and confident purchasing decisions. It also helps prevent disputes in transactions.

Helpful Tools

Collectors can use online lookup tools such as Midpoint to verify card details, access population reports, and review recent sales data. Midpoint’s database includes extensive imagery and grading information, allowing users to cross-reference their cards against known examples for precise identification.

Section 7: Is Grading Worth It? Costs, Risks, and Rewards

Factors to Consider Before Grading

• Raw Card Value: For cards valued under $50 raw, grading fees—typically $20 to $30 for basic submission tiers—may not justify the expense unless the card has exceptional condition or rarity.
• Expected Grade: Using AI pre-grading tools helps estimate whether a card is likely to receive a PSA 9 or 10. Cards estimated below 8.5 grade often do not recoup grading costs.
• Grading Fees and Turnaround: Fees vary by grader and submission tier. Premium services offer faster turnaround at higher costs. Delays in return times can impact liquidity and timing for sales.
• Market Demand: High-grade cards of popular players can sell for multiples of raw prices. Thus, grading can increase resale value, particularly for rare parallels or premium cards.

When Grading Makes Sense

Grading is generally more beneficial when cards are of higher value, exhibit near-perfect condition, or belong to limited parallels or autographed versions. For example, a raw Outburst Red parallel with excellent centering may see a significant increase in value once graded PSA 10. Similarly, autographed patch autos graded PSA 10 can fetch several thousand dollars, often justifying grading fees.

Using Midpoint to Decide

Midpoint’s precise centering measurements and AI grading predictions across PSA, BGS, CGC, and TAG scales help collectors make data-driven grading decisions. By analyzing these metrics, users can avoid submitting cards unlikely to grade well, reducing financial risk and maximizing potential returns. This approach is especially valuable for high-volume submissions or when selling cards in competitive markets.

Section 8: Selling Strategies: Marketplaces, Dealers, and Auction Platforms

Where to Sell Macklin Celebrini / Will Smith Cards

• Online Marketplaces: eBay remains a major platform for sports cards, with millions of active users and high traffic. Seller fees typically range from 10% to 15%, including PayPal and listing fees. eBay’s auction and "Buy It Now" options offer flexibility in pricing and timing.
• Dealer Offers: Local or online dealers provide quick cash sales with minimal hassle. However, dealers usually offer wholesale prices—often 30% to 50% below market value—due to inventory risk and profit margins.
• Auction Platforms: Specialized platforms like Goldin Auctions, PWCC, and Heritage Auctions cater to sports cards and memorabilia. These platforms can fetch higher prices for premium cards, especially graded PSA 10s or rare parallels, due to targeted buyers and marketing. Commissions range from 10% to 20%.

Maximizing Net Proceeds

Choosing the right selling venue depends on your priorities. For rapid sales of raw or lower-value cards, online marketplaces offer speed and convenience. For high-value graded cards, auction platforms may yield higher returns, though with longer sale cycles and fees. Packaging, shipping insurance, and communication with buyers also affect selling success. Sellers should factor these costs into net proceeds.

Use Market Data to Time Sales

Midpoint users benefit from access to recent sold-comparable prices and current market listings, enabling strategic timing of sales. Selling during peak interest periods—such as post-draft announcements, NHL season starts, or after player milestones—may enhance prices. Monitoring market saturation helps avoid listing during oversupply, which can depress values.

Conclusion

Macklin Celebrini and Will Smith cards represent a dynamic and popular segment of hockey card collecting. Understanding the nuances of the 2024 Upper Deck #499 base rookie card, its parallels, and premium versions is important for accurate valuation and smart collecting. Grading decisions can significantly affect final value, and tools like Midpoint provide collectors with AI-driven grading estimates and precise centering measurements to help optimize grading submissions and potentially maximize returns. Whether you are a seasoned collector or new investor, informed choices about card identification, grading, and selling channels can help you better navigate the market and build valuable collections or investments.

FAQ

Q: How much is a Macklin Celebrini and Will Smith rookie card worth?

A: Raw 2024 Upper Deck #499 rookie cards generally range from around $45 to $70, with graded versions potentially reaching $700 to $900 for PSA 10 as of 2026-09-03. Values vary based on condition, centering, and card version.

Q: What is the value of the 2024 Upper Deck Macklin Celebrini/Will Smith #499 card?

A: The base rookie card #499 values vary by condition and grading, with raw cards typically between $45 and $70 and PSA 10 graded cards often commanding $700 to $900, with higher values possible for rare parallels such as Deluxe, Exclusive, and Outburst Red versions.

Q: How much is a PSA 10 Macklin Celebrini/Will Smith card worth?

A: PSA 10 graded base rookie cards are generally valued between $700 and $900, while PSA 10 parallel versions like Outburst Red may exceed $1,200. Autographed and patch auto cards graded PSA 10 can reach several thousand dollars.

Q: Which Macklin Celebrini and Will Smith cards are worth the most money?

A: The most valuable cards tend to include autographed rookie patch autos, acetate cards, NHL Shield numbered parallels, and limited Outburst Red parallel versions. These cards are rare, often serial numbered, and highly sought after by collectors.

Q: Is the Macklin Celebrini/Will Smith Upper Deck card worth grading?

A: Grading is generally worthwhile if the card is in excellent condition and expected to receive a high grade (9 or 10), especially for rare parallels and premium versions. Using AI pre-grading tools like Midpoint can help determine this and avoid unnecessary grading fees.

Q: How can I tell which Macklin Celebrini/Will Smith card I have?

A: Identify your card by set name (2024 Upper Deck), card number (#499), parallel type (Deluxe, Exclusive, Outburst Red), serial numbering, and autograph authentication if applicable. Card lookup tools such as Midpoint assist with accurate identification and market pricing.