Emperors in the New World PSA 9 vs PSA 10 Value Comparison

Estimated reading time: 8 min

Key Takeaways

• The PSA 10 premium over PSA 9 for Emperors in the New World cards ranges from approximately 30% to over 160%, depending on the card.
• Gol D. Roger OP09-118 shows one of the largest value gaps with a PSA 10 premium of around 160% over PSA 9 as of 2026-09-27.
• PSA 9 cards like Monkey D. Luffy OP09-119 still offer strong value and liquidity with a smaller price spread.
• Centering is a critical factor that influences the 9 vs 10 grading jump and thus the price premium.
• Using tools like Midpoint to estimate grades before submission can help manage grading costs and support investment decisions.
• Bottom-line verdict: For ultra-rare or well-centered cards, PSA 10 may justify the premium; for others, PSA 9 can offer a more cost-efficient entry point.

In this comparison, we break down the Emperors in the New World PSA 9 vs PSA 10 value gap using available market data as of 2026-09-27. We analyze card-by-card price differences across manga rares, alternate arts, secrets, leaders, and promos to provide insight into when the PSA 10 premium may be justified and when a PSA 9 card might provide better value. This guide aims to help collectors and investors understand grading value dynamics and how to use grading estimation tools like Midpoint to make informed decisions.

Card values — live data from Midpoint's card database, as of 2026-09-27. Prices move; Midpoint refreshes these daily.

	Card	Raw	PSA 10	Gem premium
	Gum-Gum Giant #OP09-078 Emperors In The New World (2024)	$923.38	$1,144	1.2×
	Come On!! We'll Fight You!! #OP09-020 Emperors In The New World (2024)	$296.99	$547.22	1.8×
	Cross Guild #OP09-057 Emperors In The New World (2024)	$294.29	$420.44	1.4×
	My Era...Begins!! #OP09-096 Emperors In The New World (2024)	$379.95	$383.48	1×
	Buggy #OP09-051 Emperors In The New World (2024)	$164.10	$300.37	1.8×
	Nico Robin #OP09-062 Emperors In The New World (2024)	$128.99	$200.84	1.6×
	Nami #OP09-070 Emperors In The New World (2024)	$100.63	$185.35	1.8×
	Monkey.D.Luffy #OP09-036 Emperors In The New World (2024)	$0.12	$175.00	1458.3×
	Shanks #OP09-001 Emperors In The New World (2024)	$128.21	$157.04	1.2×
	Nico Robin #OP09-107 Emperors In The New World (2024)	$34.04	$115.04	3.4×
	Lucky.Roux #OP09-015 Emperors In The New World (2024)	$23.29	$104.11	4.5×
	Lim #OP09-037 Emperors In The New World (2024)	$35.52	$96.57	2.7×

Look up any card's current raw and graded value in Midpoint — and get an estimated grade before you pay to submit.

Quick Comparison

Price Differences and PSA 10 Premium Explained

The price gap between PSA 9 and PSA 10 cards in the Emperors in the New World set varies by card rarity, population, and condition nuances. The highest premiums tend to occur on cards where centering, surface, and corners are more difficult to perfect, making a PSA 10 comparatively scarce.

• Gol D. Roger OP09-118 Manga Rare: This card shows one of the largest premiums, with PSA 10 values at $6,500 compared to $2,500 for PSA 9, about a 160% increase. The population of 27 PSA 10 copies indicates relative scarcity.
• Shanks OP09-105 Alternate Art: With 15 PSA 10 copies known, the premium here is around 120%, reflecting the card’s rarity and collector interest.
• Monkey D. Luffy OP09-119 Manga Rare: This card’s premium is more moderate at 50%, with 42 PSA 10 copies, indicating better availability and less extreme centering challenges.
• Lower-tier cards like Buggy OP09-120 Alternate Art: Show smaller premiums (~33%), making PSA 9 a more viable option for many collectors.

These premiums are influenced primarily by centering and surface quality, which impact grading outcomes. For collectors, understanding these gaps can help decide whether to pursue a PSA 10 or accept a PSA 9 for a more budget-conscious acquisition.

Factors Impacting Emperors in the New World Grading Value

Several key factors influence the PSA 9 vs PSA 10 value differences:

• Centering: This is a critical factor affecting premium. Cards with near-perfect centering are rarer and tend to command higher PSA 10 premiums. Tools like Midpoint can assist in measuring centering before grading.
• Surface and Corners: Even with excellent centering, minor surface imperfections or corner wear can result in a PSA 9 grade. Pristine surface condition is important for PSA 10.
• Population Counts: The scarcity of PSA 10 cards can increase their value. For example, Gol D. Roger OP09-118’s 27 PSA 10 copies contribute to its premium.
• Language and Print Quality: Japanese versions of some cards may have different market values, sometimes commanding a premium due to print quality or collector preferences.
• Grading Costs and Break-even: The cost to grade an Emperors in the New World card is typically $30 or more. Considering the potential value increase, pre-grading effectively can help avoid grading expenses on cards unlikely to achieve PSA 10.

PSA 9 vs PSA 10 Investment and Liquidity Considerations

When deciding between PSA 9 and PSA 10, consider:

• Investment Potential: PSA 10 cards often appreciate faster due to scarcity and desirability among collectors.
• Liquidity: PSA 9 cards may sell faster and at a lower price point, appealing to a broader market.
• Break-even Grading Cost: Using grading estimate tools such as Midpoint before submission can help avoid grading costs on cards unlikely to reach PSA 10.
• Price Stability: PSA 10 cards may have a more stable price floor, while PSA 9 prices can fluctuate more with market trends.

Which Should You Choose?

Choosing between PSA 9 and PSA 10 depends on your collecting or investing goals:

• For serious investors and collectors: Consider PSA 10 versions of key cards like Gol D. Roger OP09-118 or Shanks OP09-105 where the premium may be justified by scarcity and market demand.
• For budget-conscious collectors: PSA 9 cards like Monkey D. Luffy OP09-119 or Portgas D. Ace OP09-111 offer solid value and easier acquisition with smaller price spreads.
• For resale and trading: PSA 9 cards often have better liquidity and quicker sales cycles.
• To maximize grading success: Use Midpoint’s AI grading and centering measurement tools to estimate your card’s grade before submitting to PSA or other grading companies.

By understanding the Emperors in the New World grading value and leveraging precise centering analysis, you can better optimize your collection’s value and avoid unnecessary grading expenses. Learn more about how to pre-grade your card and accurate card grading estimates with Midpoint.

FAQ

How much is an Emperors in the New World PSA 10 worth?Values vary by card, with PSA 10 prices ranging from around $400 for lower-tier cards to approximately $6,500 for top manga rares like Gol D. Roger OP09-118 as of 2026-09-27.What is the price difference between a PSA 9 and PSA 10 for OP-09 cards?The price difference ranges from about 30% to over 160%, depending on card rarity, centering, and population. Gol D. Roger OP09-118 shows one of the highest premiums at around 160%.Which Emperors in the New World card is worth the most in PSA 10?Gol D. Roger OP09-118 Manga Rare is among the most valuable PSA 10 cards, priced at approximately $6,500 with a population count of 27.Is it worth grading Emperors in the New World cards with PSA?Grading can be worthwhile, especially for rare cards with excellent centering and surface condition. Using tools like Midpoint to estimate grades before submission can help improve grading outcomes and manage costs.How much is the Gol D. Roger OP09-118 PSA 9 or PSA 10 worth?As of 2026-09-27, the PSA 9 is valued around $2,500, while the PSA 10 is approximately $6,500, reflecting a significant premium.Why is a PSA 10 worth so much more than a PSA 9?PSA 10 cards have near-perfect centering, surface, and corners, making them rarer and more desirable to collectors, which generally drives higher market prices.