Justin Herbert Cards Worth Money: A Collector’s Guide to Value & Grading

Estimated reading time: 15 min

Key Takeaways

• Justin Herbert cards that tend to hold value include key rookie cards, autographs, and low-numbered parallels such as National Treasures and Prizm Black Finite, which are often sought after due to their relative rarity and collector demand.
• PSA 10 and BGS 9.5 graded cards generally increase value, with some examples reaching higher price points, reflecting the premium collectors place on near-perfect condition.
• Card condition, centering, and autograph authentication are important factors in determining value; Midpoint’s AI grading tool can help estimate grades before submission, potentially reducing grading costs and aiding investment decisions.
• Affordable options under $100 exist, including base and Holo rookie cards from popular 2020 sets, making collecting accessible for newcomers.
• Rarity from serial-numbered parallels, 1/1 cards, and special inserts often drives higher prices, highlighting the importance of understanding card variants and print runs.

Card values — live data from Midpoint's card database, as of 2026-09-04. Prices move; Midpoint refreshes these daily.

	Card	Raw	PSA 10	Gem premium
	Justin Herbert [Gold] #K9 2022 Panini Absolute Kaboom Vertical	$2,070	$10,456	5.1×
	Justin Herbert [Spectrum Gold] #1 2023 Panini Absolute	$28.98	$8,250	284.7×
	Justin Herbert [Gold] #2 2023 Panini Absolute Kaboom Horizontal	—	$7,000	—
	Justin Herbert #K-JH1 2020 Panini Absolute Kaboom	$3,149	$6,938	2.2×
	Justin Herbert #K-JH2 2020 Panini Absolute Kaboom	$1,924	$5,697	3×
	Justin Herbert / Quentin Johnston [Gold] #6 2024 Panini Donruss Optic Downtown Duos	$2,728	$5,525	2×
	Justin Herbert [Emerald] #103 2020 Panini Flawless	$3,100	$5,183	1.7×
	Justin Herbert / Ladd McConkey #19 2024 Panini Donruss Downtown Horizontal	$1,021	$3,287	3.2×
	Justin Herbert #DT-31 2020 Panini Donruss Optic Downtown	$1,238	$3,059	2.5×
	Jim Harbaugh / Justin Herbert #4 2025 Panini Donruss Optic Downtown Duo	$675.00	$3,024	4.5×
	Justin Herbert [Autograph Red] #104 2020 Panini Contenders Optic	$860.00	$2,800	3.3×
	Justin Herbert [Materials Autograph] #203 2020 Panini Absolute	$290.11	$2,640	9.1×

Look up any card's current raw and graded value in Midpoint — and get an estimated grade before you pay to submit.

Table of Contents

• Section 1: Understanding Justin Herbert Cards Worth Money
• Section 2: Most Valuable Justin Herbert Cards & Their Market Prices
• Section 3: In-Depth Look at Justin Herbert Rookie Card Value
• Section 4: How Grading Affects Justin Herbert Card Values
• Section 5: Autographed and Memorabilia Cards: Worth the Investment?
• Section 6: Rarity & Parallel Variants Driving Premium Prices
• Section 7: Smart Buying: Best Justin Herbert Cards to Grade and Collect

Conclusion

FAQ

Section 1: Understanding Justin Herbert Cards Worth Money

Why Justin Herbert Cards Are Popular Among Collectors

Justin Herbert has quickly become one of the NFL’s notable quarterbacks, making his trading cards popular among collectors. His performance since entering the league in 2020, including multiple Pro Bowl selections and notable rookie statistics, has contributed to his recognition as a key player and a rising star in the hobby.

Collectors value his cards not only for his on-field achievements but also for their potential long-term appreciation in the hobby market. As Herbert continues his career, early cards—especially rookies and limited parallels—are often viewed as potential investments.

Additionally, Herbert’s personality, endorsements, and media presence contribute to his cards’ appeal. The combination of performance and marketability supports ongoing demand, even amid market fluctuations.

Key Factors That Determine a Card’s Worth

Several factors influence which Justin Herbert cards may be worth money:

• Card Set and Year: Rookie cards from 2020 and premium sets like National Treasures often command higher prices because they represent the player's entry point into the hobby and frequently feature high-quality production and limited runs.
• Condition and Grading: Higher grades such as PSA 10 or BGS 9.5 typically increase value. Cards with good centering, sharp corners, clean edges, and pristine surfaces are preferred.
• Rarity and Parallels: Limited print runs, serial-numbered parallels (e.g., /10, /25), 1/1 cards, and special editions tend to be more valuable due to scarcity.
• Autographs and Patches: Cards featuring authenticated autographs and memorabilia patches (jersey swatches) often attract higher prices because they add uniqueness and player connection.
• Market Trends: Player performance, team success, media exposure, and general hobby demand affect prices. Positive news, playoff appearances, or MVP-caliber seasons can influence price movements.

Using Midpoint to Evaluate Justin Herbert Cards

Before investing in grading, collectors can use Midpoint’s AI-powered grading and centering tools to estimate a card’s PSA, BGS, CGC, or TAG grade. This may help identify which cards are worth grading versus those less likely to achieve premium grades.

Midpoint analyzes high-resolution images to assess centering percentages, corners, edges, and surface quality, providing a grade prediction with confidence intervals. This can be useful given grading fees often exceed $30 per card, plus shipping.

Midpoint also aggregates recent sales data across marketplaces, offering up-to-date raw and graded values to help collectors gauge current market worth and trends for specific card variants.

Section 2: Most Valuable Justin Herbert Cards & Their Market Prices

Top Justin Herbert Cards by Value as of 2026-09-04

According to Midpoint’s database, some of the more valuable Justin Herbert cards include:

• 2020 National Treasures Rookie Patch Autograph #158 – raw prices often exceed $1,200; PSA 10 examples have been known to reach several thousand dollars, making it a highly sought-after card. This card features a multi-colored jersey patch and Herbert’s on-card autograph, combining rarity with premium aesthetics.
• Panini Prizm Black Finite #325 – a limited parallel with serial numbers under 100; PSA 10 cards have traded for high prices. This card’s design and low print run make it desirable among collectors.
• National Treasures Gold Parallels – numbered out of 10 or less, these autographed cards can command premium prices in top grades. The gold foil and limited availability contribute to their value.
• Contenders Optic Rookie Ticket #153 – a popular insert rookie ticket with demand; PSA 10 versions have sold for several hundred dollars. The insert’s autograph potential and unique rookie ticket design appeal to collectors.
• Donruss Optic Rated Rookie #153 – affordable raw versions under $50, PSA 10 graded cards can reach higher values. This card is a common entry point for collectors seeking value in the Herbert rookie class.

1/1 and Super Rare Cards

Ultra-rare 1-of-1 cards such as Superfractors (a Prizm variant with a distinctive refractor pattern) and NFL Shield inserts can command prices well above typical ranges if in pristine condition and authenticated. These represent the pinnacle of rarity and are often sold through private sales or high-profile auctions.

Examples include:

• 2020 Panini Prizm Superfractor #325 1/1 – has sold for high prices depending on condition and provenance.
• National Treasures NFL Shield 1/1 inserts – prized for unique design and scarcity, sometimes fetching premium amounts.

Collectors with significant resources may target these cards as trophy pieces or long-term investments.

Market Fluctuations and Recent Sales Trends

Market interest in Justin Herbert cards often correlates with his NFL performance and team success. For example, during playoff pushes or after standout games, certain card prices may experience temporary increases.

Injuries or slumps can temporarily affect prices, but long-term trends may remain positive as Herbert is still early in his career. National Treasures and Prizm Black Finite cards have shown periods of appreciation, with some annual gains reported, consistent with other top-tier quarterback cards.

Collectors should monitor Midpoint’s market trend tools to identify potential buying or selling opportunities based on recent sales velocity and price stability.

Section 3: In-Depth Look at Justin Herbert Rookie Card Value

Best 2020 Rookie Cards to Own

The 2020 rookie crop features several notable Justin Herbert cards that collectors often target, largely due to their quality, print runs, and set prestige. Key examples include:

• Panini Prizm #325: The flagship Prizm rookie card, collectible with raw values around $80-$100 and PSA 10 prices that have approached several hundred dollars. Variants such as Holo and Silver Prizms may command slight premiums.
• Donruss Optic Rated Rookie #153: A popular parallel with solid value; raw copies often under $50 and PSA 10 graded cards have sold for higher amounts. Its accessibility makes it a favorite for budget-conscious collectors.
• Contenders Optic Rookie Ticket: Known for its autograph potential, this card’s rookie ticket inserts can be rare and valuable, especially autographed versions. Raw non-autograph versions generally trade within a moderate price range.
• National Treasures Rookie Patch Autograph #158: A premium rookie card, featuring a patch and autograph; PSA 10 values have been reported in the thousands. This card is considered highly desirable for Herbert collectors due to limited print runs and premium materials.

Raw vs Graded Rookie Card Values

Raw rookie cards can be affordable entry points but often trade for a fraction of their graded counterparts. For example, a raw Panini Prizm #325 might sell for around $80, whereas a PSA 10 example can fetch several hundred dollars or more, illustrating the value premium grading can bring.

Similarly, Donruss Optic Rated Rookie raw cards may be priced in the $40-$50 range, while PSA 10 examples have sold for higher amounts, representing a notable increase.

This value gap emphasizes the importance of condition and professional grading, as collectors and investors prioritize cards with verified quality.

How to Identify Legit Rookie Cards

Look for the following indicators on Justin Herbert rookie cards to help ensure authenticity and value:

• Rookie Designation: Cards often feature "RC" logos or "Rated Rookie" markings prominently on the front or back, signaling their rookie status.
• Card Set and Number: Verify with checklist databases or trusted sources to ensure authenticity and correct numbering (e.g., Panini Prizm #325). Misnumbered or counterfeit cards exist in the market.
• Print Runs and Parallels: Some rookie cards have multiple parallel versions (Holo, Gold, Black Finite) affecting rarity and value. Identifying the correct parallel variant is important.
• Autograph Presence: Rookie cards with authentic autographs generally command higher prices; ensure autograph authentication (PSA/DNA or BGS) when possible.
• Condition and Corners: Even raw cards with sharp corners and good centering tend to hold more value, especially if candidates for grading.

Section 4: How Grading Affects Justin Herbert Card Values

Grading Companies and Their Impact

PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator), BGS (Beckett Grading Services), CGC (Certified Guaranty Company), and TAG Grading are primary grading companies impacting Justin Herbert card values. Each has distinct grading scales and reputation levels:

• PSA: The most recognized grading company with strong market influence. PSA 10 (Gem Mint) cards typically command the highest premiums.
• BGS: Known for subgrades (centering, edges, corners, surface) and popular among collectors seeking detailed condition insights. BGS 9.5 (Gem Mint) is highly prized.
• CGC: Gaining recognition, especially for modern cards, with similar grading standards.
• TAG Grading: Newer but respected for fast turnaround and comparable grading accuracy.

Midpoint’s AI grading estimates can help predict likely grades before expensive submissions, enabling smarter investment decisions.

Centering, Corners, Edges, and Surface

These four condition aspects determine the numeric grade. Centering is often the toughest to perfect and can cause a card to drop a full grade if off by just a few percentage points. For instance, PSA generally requires 55/45 or better centering for a 10 on most cards.

Midpoint’s precise centering tool measures card centering down to the millimeter, providing confidence before paying $30+ for grading. Additionally, the tool evaluates corners for sharpness, edges for wear or chipping, and surface for scratches or print defects.

For example, a card with perfect centering but slightly worn corners might receive a BGS 9 instead of 9.5 or 10, impacting value significantly.

Value Differences by Grade

Consider the 2020 Panini Prizm #325 rookie card as an example:

• Raw average value: around $80
• PSA 9: approximately $250
• PSA 10: around $600

The value jump underscores the importance of grading high-quality cards. Cards graded PSA 8 or below typically see a more modest premium, often only 1.5-2x raw value.

Similarly, National Treasures Rookie Patch Autographs graded PSA 10 can command prices notably higher than PSA 9 examples, emphasizing the premium collectors place on perfection.

Authenticated Autographs and Grading

Autographed Justin Herbert cards graded and authenticated by PSA/DNA or BGS with verified signatures generally see higher value, sometimes significantly more than ungraded autograph cards. Authentication ensures buyer confidence and reduces fraud risk.

For example, a raw National Treasures RPA may sell for around $1,000, while a PSA 10 with PSA/DNA autograph authentication can command several thousand dollars.

To learn more about how grading affects card value, check out this detailed guide on Card Grade Impact on Insurance Value.

Section 5: Autographed and Memorabilia Cards: Worth the Investment?

Types of Justin Herbert Autographed Cards

Autographed cards come in several varieties, including:

• Standard Autographs: On-card or sticker autographs without additional memorabilia, often found in sets like Panini Contenders or Donruss Optic.
• Rookie Patch Autographs (RPA): Featuring a jersey patch and autograph, typically from National Treasures or Contenders sets. These combine autograph rarity with memorabilia, often boosting value.
• Serial-Numbered Autographs: Cards limited to certain print runs, e.g., /10 or /25, enhancing scarcity and desirability.
• 1/1 Autographs: Unique one-of-one cards, often Superfractors or special insert autographs, commanding the highest prices.

Value and Price Ranges

As of 2026-09-04, the National Treasures Rookie Patch Autograph #158 graded PSA 10 can command values in the thousands of dollars. Lower-tier autographed cards or ungraded RPAs may sell for lower amounts, offering different entry points.

For example, a 2020 Contenders Optic Rookie Ticket Autograph graded PSA 10 might trade in the mid-hundreds to over a thousand dollars based on scarcity and condition.

Collectors should evaluate autograph placement, ink quality, and card condition, as these affect desirability.

Memorabilia and Patch Cards

Cards containing pieces of game-worn jerseys or other memorabilia patches generally increase value, especially those with unique colors or designs (e.g., multi-colored patches, team logos). The combination of autograph plus patch is often highly desirable and commands a premium.

For instance, a National Treasures RPA featuring a multi-colored patch from Herbert's rookie season can be worth more than a similar autograph-only card.

Authentication Importance

Authentication by PSA/DNA or BGS is important; without it, autographed cards often see a discount, sometimes significant. Midpoint helps identify legitimate autographed cards by assessing authenticity indicators and verifying seller reputation.

Collectors should be cautious with uncertified autographs to minimize risk of forgery and ensure long-term value retention.

Section 6: Rarity & Parallel Variants Driving Premium Prices

Low-Numbered Parallels

Gold parallels numbered to 10 or less, Black Finite parallels, and Superfractors (1/1) represent some of the rarest Justin Herbert cards. These cards can sell for several thousand dollars, especially at PSA 10 or BGS 9.5 grades.

For example, a National Treasures Gold Parallel numbered /10 graded PSA 10 can command high prices, while a Black Finite parallel graded PSA 10 can also fetch premium amounts.

Collectors prize these parallels for their scarcity and visual appeal, often displaying them as centerpiece cards.

Serial Numbers and Print Runs

Collectors seek cards with low serial numbers (e.g., /1 to /10) as they indicate extreme scarcity. For instance, a National Treasures Gold Parallel /10 graded PSA 10 can command premium prices, while a /25 parallel may fetch lower but still notable amounts.

Understanding print runs is essential; some parallels have print runs of hundreds or thousands, which diminishes rarity and value.

NFL Shield and Other Special Inserts

NFL Shield cards and other special inserts with limited print runs or unique design features attract premium prices. These inserts are often 1/1 or very low serial numbers and highly collectible.

For example, a National Treasures NFL Shield 1/1 insert graded PSA 10 can command high prices, driven by ultra-low print runs and striking design.

The impact of rarity on value highlights why precise card identification and condition grading are important. Midpoint’s comprehensive lookup and grading tools help collectors navigate this complexity, ensuring they recognize valuable parallels and avoid overpaying for common variants.

Section 7: Smart Buying: Best Justin Herbert Cards to Grade and Collect

Affordable Cards Worth Grading

Not all valuable cards require a high upfront investment. Some of the best Justin Herbert cards to grade under $100 raw include:

• Panini Prizm Base Rookie #325 – raw copies often found between $80-$100, grading to PSA 10 can multiply value significantly.
• Donruss Optic Rated Rookie #153 – widely available raw for $40-$50, grading can yield PSA 10 values higher than raw.
• Contenders Optic Rookie Ticket (non-autograph versions) – raw prices typically $70-$120, with PSA 10 grades selling for higher amounts.

Grading these cards at PSA 10 or BGS 9.5 can multiply values by several times, making them suitable for collectors seeking growth potential without high risk.

Evaluating Cards for Grading with Midpoint

Using Midpoint’s AI grading and centering tools allows collectors to pre-grade cards with reasonable accuracy (often within a half-grade difference), helping avoid costly grading fees on cards unlikely to score PSA 9 or higher.

Steps to evaluate a card with Midpoint:

1. Upload a high-resolution, well-lit photo of the card.
2. Review the AI-generated grade estimate and centering percentages.
3. Compare the estimated grade with market values to assess potential return on grading investment.
4. Decide whether to submit the card for grading based on predicted grade and value.

This process can reduce grading waste, optimize spending, and help build a quality collection.

Where to Buy and Sell Justin Herbert Cards

Reputable marketplaces like eBay with sold listings data provide transparent pricing. Use Midpoint’s card lookup feature to cross-reference raw and graded values before buying or selling, helping ensure fair market transactions.

Other platforms include:

• COMC (Check Out My Cards) – for buying and consigning cards with authentication.
• StockX – primarily for high-end graded cards, offering transparent pricing.
• Facebook Groups and Local Card Shops – for community-based buying and selling, though prices may vary.

Protecting Your Investment

Proper card storage and protection help preserve condition, which is critical for maintaining grading and resale value. Recommendations include:

• Using penny sleeves and semi-rigid top loaders for raw cards.
• Storing graded cards in protective cases, avoiding exposure to sunlight or moisture.
• Maintaining a stable environment with low humidity and temperature control.
• Handling cards by edges and avoiding direct contact with surfaces to prevent oils or scratches.

For tips on storing valuable cards, explore this ultimate collector's guide to card storage.

Conclusion

Understanding which Justin Herbert cards may be worth money involves knowledge of card sets, rarity, grading, and market trends. Top rookie cards like the 2020 National Treasures Rookie Patch Autograph #158 and Panini Prizm Black Finite are among the most valuable. Grading with PSA or BGS can significantly increase value, especially for cards with strong centering and condition.

Midpoint’s app is a useful tool for collectors to pre-grade cards, track portfolio values, and make informed buying or selling decisions. Whether you’re a seasoned investor or new collector, leveraging AI grading and market data can help maximize the return on your Justin Herbert card investments.

Start exploring your collection today with Midpoint to discover which Justin Herbert cards hold value and which may be good candidates for grading.

FAQ

Q: How much is a Justin Herbert rookie card worth?

A: The value varies by card and condition. For example, a raw Panini Prizm #325 rookie card typically sells around $80, while a PSA 10 graded version can fetch several hundred dollars or more as of 2026-09-04. Grading and rarity significantly impact pricing.

Q: What is the most valuable Justin Herbert card?

A: The 2020 National Treasures Rookie Patch Autograph #158 in PSA 10 condition is among the most valuable, often selling for several thousand dollars. Ultra-rare 1/1 inserts and low-numbered parallels can command even higher prices.

Q: Which Justin Herbert rookie cards are worth money?

A: Key rookie cards that tend to hold value include Panini Prizm #325, Donruss Optic Rated Rookie #153, Contenders Optic Rookie Ticket, and National Treasures Rookie Patch Autograph #158. Parallel versions and autographed RPAs typically add value.

Q: How much is a Justin Herbert Prizm rookie card worth?

A: Raw Panini Prizm #325 cards generally sell for around $80, while PSA 10 graded examples can reach several hundred dollars or more as of the latest data. Rare parallel variants can command higher prices.

Q: Are Justin Herbert autographed cards worth money?

A: Yes, autographed cards, especially authenticated ones like National Treasures RPAs, can command higher prices, often ranging from hundreds to several thousand dollars depending on grade and rarity.

Q: What is the rarest Justin Herbert card?

A: The rarest are 1-of-1 Superfractors, low-numbered Gold Parallels, and NFL Shield insert cards, which can sell for several thousand dollars each. These cards are extremely limited and prized by high-end collectors.